Why change the check test?

The check test was changed as a result of many factors. One being the need for a recognition of more up to date teaching styles, and to encourage extra education amongst instructors.  In 2007 the transport select committee heard evidence to support change, and typically it has taken some years to come about.

However there is considered to be another reason, unconfirmed as political moves are never announced until the ink is dry, that testing will be delivered by an outside agency, therefore all ADI's need to have their check test grade replaced with the new A or B system.  Cardington would continue to train examiners for private companies who win the tender, similar to the tendering process of theory tests. The role then of the DVSA senior examiners would be quality control.

To pass the mantel with testing they would need to have a more simplex system, so an A, B or fail is much easier to train an outside agency with than the previous more complex, three pass or three fail grades.

EU inspired conversations have led to this in the light of making testing of instructors more cost effective, so the standards check fee would not go directly to the DVSA in future, but be processed independently.

The standards check has seen more fails than the previous test, but is that due to examiners coming to grips with the system or a reality.  There has been so much consideration to the current part three being replaced with teaching qualifications, that some companies actually ask for PTTLS or equivalent for their trainers. There would need to be a direct relation between driver training and teaching so this has stalled the progress. It is however subject to change.

Many believe the part three system isn't robust enough, yet many instructors who qualified through that system have delivered safe young drivers, so the system cannot be so flawed. There are a minority who would seek huge change, but then say this is not a career to enter.  If the entry is to be improved then the public awareness of the role of the instructor and the impact on the safety of their students needs more clarification. It also would then need to see a suitable fee for the work carried out. After all I have never seen a dentist or plumber offering first visit free.

So is the change to the check test to protect young lives? Essentially that is the carrot. The stick is who will be controlling it.